Skip to main content

Find a therapist in Orchard Park, NY — covered by insurance

Therapist and patient in a therapy session
Calculator Illustration
Get a cost estimate
People with insurance pay as low as $0 per session through Headway

Top therapists in Orchard Park, NY accepting new patients

Orchard Park residents can access quality mental health care through Headway's network of 8,364 providers experienced in treating anxiety, depression, and more. Sessions are flexible—choose virtual or in-person appointments with insurance accepted. Start your free intake call today and find your right fit.

Caroline Horrigan-Maurer

Caroline Horrigan-Maurer

Therapist

Virtual & in-person • 15 mi away • Buffalo, NY


“As a trauma-focused therapist, I help individuals understand and reshape their relationship with stress.”
Anxiety, Chronic conditions, Depression, End of life care, Family issues
Affirming, Empowering, Holistic
Accepts 11 insurance carriers

Offers free consultationsView profile and book
Mary-Elizabeth Belton

Mary-Elizabeth Belton

Therapist

Virtual & in-person • 16 mi away • Buffalo, NY


“Mary offers nonjudgmental compassion, approachability, creativity, insight, and humor through an eclectic mix of evidence based treatments approaches.”
ADD/ADHD, Anxiety, Depression, Family issues, Grief or loss
Creative, Empowering, Humorous
Accepts 18 insurance carriers
Deborah Schwagler

Deborah Schwagler

Therapist

Virtual & in-person • 16 mi away • Buffalo, NY


“I am a licensed mental health counselor with diagnostic privileges, specializing in trauma-informed care.”
ADD/ADHD, Anger management, Anxiety, Cultural & ethnic issues, Depression
Open-minded, Solution-oriented, Warm
Accepts 6 insurance carriers
Michael Guerin

Michael Guerin

Therapist

Virtual & in-person • 15 mi away • Buffalo, NY


“It is my belief that we have an innate ability to be resilient at times in which our lens may become scratched, foggy, or even cracked.”
Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Depression, End of life care, Grief or loss
Holistic, Solution-oriented, Warm
Accepts 10 insurance carriers
Michelle Volpe

Michelle Volpe

Therapist

Virtual & in-person • 16 mi away • Buffalo, NY


“I specialize in working with children, teens and adults with anxiety, depression, ODD, ADHD, bipolar infertility, and much more.”
ADD/ADHD, Anger management, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Depression
Open-minded, Solution-oriented, Warm
Accepts 3 insurance carriers

Offers free consultationsView profile and book
Patrick Greene

Patrick Greene

Therapist

Virtual & in-person • 16 mi away • Buffalo, NY


“Many people I work with are used to holding a lot on their own. On the outside, they may appear capable and put together, while internally feeling overwhelmed, emotionally exhausted, anxious, disconnected, or stuck in patterns they cannot seem to...”
ADD/ADHD, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Chronic conditions, Cultural & ethnic issues
Affirming, Holistic, Warm
Accepts 7 insurance carriers

Offers free consultationsView profile and book
Eric Todd

Eric Todd

Therapist

Virtual & in-person • 16 mi away • Buffalo, NY


“I take a nonjudgmental approach that balances an appreciation for who you are and the challenges you are facing along with a compassionate push for change and growth.”
Anxiety, Depression, Grief or loss, Identity issues, PTSD
Affirming, Open-minded, Warm
Accepts 7 insurance carriers
Jill Lyons

Jill Lyons

Therapist

Virtual & in-person • 16 mi away • Amherst, NY


“I provide a comforting, safe space which allows for growth, empowerment, and change in the lives of clients.”
Anger management, Anxiety, Depression, Family issues, Grief or loss
Empowering, Open-minded, Solution-oriented
Accepts 8 insurance carriers
Timothy Greco

Timothy Greco

Psychiatric Mental Health NP

Virtual & in-person • 17 mi away • Kenmore, NY


“Each session includes supportive psychotherapy, which gives patients the chance to talk through their challenges and build new coping skills.”
Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Chronic conditions, Depression, Identity issues
Holistic, Participatory, Solution-oriented
Accepts 12 insurance carriers

Offers free consultationsView profile and book
Holly McCarty

Holly McCarty

Therapist

Virtual & in-person • 17 mi away • Tonawanda, NY


“I specialize in mental health and behavioral health disorders such as depression, anxiety, bipolar, PTSD, ADHD, and oppositional defiant disorder...”
ADD/ADHD, Anger management, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Depression
Empowering, Open-minded, Warm
Accepts 14 insurance carriers

Offers free consultationsView profile and book
Abigail Nunn

Abigail Nunn

Therapist

Virtual & in-person • 17 mi away • Tonawanda, NY


“At the heart of my practice as a holistic trauma therapist is the belief that everyone deserves to feel heard, supported, and encouraged...”
ADD/ADHD, Anxiety, Depression, Eating disorders, Grief or loss
Affirming, Humorous, Warm
Accepts 3 insurance carriers
Sunny Sisley

Sunny Sisley

Therapist

Virtual & in-person • 17 mi away • Getzville, NY


Hello! I am a licensed mental health counselor (LMHC), and I am committed to helping you feel supported and understood from day one through your life's challenges with compassion and care. My training and clinical experience have equipped me to work with people facing anxiety, depression, relationship concerns, and life transitions. I strive to create a safe, nonjudgmental space where you can feel respected and heard. My goal is to help you build insight, resilience, and practical tools for lasting emotional well-being.

Anger management, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Depression, Panic disorders
Empowering, Open-minded, Solution-oriented
Accepts 15 insurance carriers
Kristen Wojtaszek

Kristen Wojtaszek

Therapist

Virtual & in-person • 17 mi away • Buffalo, NY


“I believe therapy works best when you feel genuinely heard, understood, and supported without judgment.”
ADD/ADHD, Anger management, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Chronic conditions
Affirming, Open-minded, Warm
Accepts 3 insurance carriers
Paige Schultze

Paige Schultze

Therapist

Virtual & in-person • 17 mi away • Buffalo, NY


“My style is warm, nonjudgmental, and collaborative. I tailor my approach to each individual, focusing on the underlying root of individuals' challenges...”
ADD/ADHD, Anger management, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Chronic conditions
Affirming, Open-minded, Warm
Accepts 4 insurance carriers
Lauren Lutey

Lauren Lutey

Therapist

Virtual & in-person • 17 mi away • Buffalo, NY


“I balance compassion with gentle challenge—supporting you while also helping you recognize patterns that may be keeping you stuck.”
ADD/ADHD, Anger management, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Chronic conditions
Direct, Empowering, Open-minded
Accepts 3 insurance carriers
Harrison Ta-Smith

Harrison Ta-Smith

Therapist

Virtual & in-person • 17 mi away • Buffalo, NY


“I take a person-centered approach and strive to create a safe space where you or your child can feel heard, understood, and supported.”
ADD/ADHD, Anger management, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Depression
Empowering, Humorous, Open-minded
Accepts 3 insurance carriers
Lindsey Bala

Lindsey Bala

Therapist

Virtual & in-person • 17 mi away • Amherst, NY


Hi, I’m Lindsey, a psychotherapist who works with adult (18+) individuals navigating a wide range of emotional, relational, and life challenges. I believe the most effective therapy is a collaborative process where we work together as a team to identify what’s not working and build practical, meaningful solutions that fit your life. My goal is to help you feel supported, understood, and actively involved in your own healing.

We begin by building a strong therapeutic alliance—creating a space that feels safe, nonjudgmental, and grounded in trust. From there, we explore your specific needs, patterns, and goals in a way that feels respectful of your pace and readiness.

ADD/ADHD, Anger management, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Depression
Affirming, Empowering, Warm
Accepts 3 insurance carriers
Jane Moeller

Jane Moeller

Therapist

Virtual & in-person • 14 mi away • Williamsville, NY


“I believe that growth occurs through understanding how one's past circumstances can impact their present functioning.”
ADD/ADHD, Anxiety, Cultural & ethnic issues, Depression, Identity issues
Affirming, Humorous, Open-minded
Accepts 9 insurance carriers
Amber Blanchard

Amber Blanchard

Therapist

Virtual & in-person • 14 mi away • Williamsville, NY


“I specialize in the treatment of trauma through the use of Eye Movement Desensitization Reprocessing (EMDR).”
Anxiety, Depression, Family issues, Infertility, Maternal mental health
Inquisitive, Open-minded, Warm
Accepts 9 insurance carriers

Offers free consultationsView profile and book
Amy Pfeffer

Amy Pfeffer

Therapist

Virtual & in-person • 16 mi away • Amherst, NY


“I help to empower my clients to resolve issues, achieve growth, and respond to challenges in a healthy way.”
ADD/ADHD, Anger management, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Cultural & ethnic issues
Empowering, Humorous, Open-minded
Accepts 9 insurance carriers
Alicia Kohlhagen

Alicia Kohlhagen

Therapist

Virtual & in-person • 17 mi away • Buffalo, NY


“I believe that safety and stabilization including trust building is an incredibly important step in therapy and aim to foster that and empowerment throughout treatment.”
Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Depression, Identity issues, Infertility
Affirming, Empowering, Warm
Accepts 7 insurance carriers

Offers free consultationsView profile and book
Lindy Kadish

Lindy Kadish

Therapist

Virtual & in-person • 19 mi away • East Amherst, NY


“Through this approach I balance self-acceptance with encouraging clients to make meaningful changes that will ultimately bring them emotional freedom and more control over their lives.”
Anxiety, Depression, Identity issues, PTSD, Trauma
Affirming, Inquisitive, Open-minded
Accepts 12 insurance carriers

Offers free consultationsView profile and book
Tali Schwiethale

Tali Schwiethale

Therapist

Virtual & in-person • 17 mi away • Buffalo, NY


“My approach is warm, collaborative, and person-centered. I strive to meet you where you are, listen without judgment...”
ADD/ADHD, Anger management, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Depression
Affirming, Empowering, Warm
Accepts 3 insurance carriers
Bernard Huber

Bernard Huber

Therapist

Virtual & in-person • 27 mi away • Niagara Falls, NY


“Together, we will begin identifying priorities for therapy and discuss an approach that feels comfortable, practical, and tailored to your needs.”
ADD/ADHD, Anger management, Anxiety, Depression, Family issues
Creative, Direct, Warm
Accepts 4 insurance carriers
Michelle Truax

Michelle Truax

Therapist

Virtual & in-person • Fredonia, NY


“I believe that every person and experience is unique and treatment should reflect upon the needs of the individual.”
Anxiety, Depression, Family issues, Maternal mental health, OCD
Affirming, Empowering, Solution-oriented
Accepts 15 insurance carriers
Elizabeth Kern

Elizabeth Kern

Therapist

Virtual & in-person • 19 mi away • Buffalo, NY


“My goal as a therapist is to help you make the best out of the difficult times and learn ways to better understand and manage the stressors of your everyday life.”
Anxiety, Depression, Family issues, Identity issues, PTSD
Open-minded, Solution-oriented, Warm
Accepts 8 insurance carriers
Osaze Ibhawa

Osaze Ibhawa

Therapist

Virtual & in-person • Jamestown, NY


“He works with individuals using an eclectic/integrative approach, and utilizes variety of interventions/techniques that includes, but not limited to, CBT, DBT, REBT, EMDR, MI and SFT.”
Anger management, Anxiety, Depression, PTSD, Substance use / addiction
Creative, Empowering, Holistic
Accepts 18 insurance carriers
Kaleb Colosimo

Kaleb Colosimo

Therapist

Virtual & in-person • Rochester, NY


Welcome - I'm so glad you're here! I know finding a therapist can be daunting, but it is so worth it when you find someone you can trust. Whether you are navigating a new challenge life has thrown at you or are choosing to tackle a longstanding problem, I would be honored to be part of your team. Clients from all walks of life are welcome. I value clients' diversity and aim to treat each individual as holistically as possible. If you are looking to grow yourself and your relationships into the best that they can be, I would love to meet with you and accompany you on that journey.

ADD/ADHD, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Depression, Family issues
Affirming, Humorous, Inquisitive
Accepts 7 insurance carriers

Offers free consultationsView profile and book
Emily Wolbert

Emily Wolbert

Therapist

Virtual & in-person • Rochester, NY


“I believe that feeling truly understood and having a safe, trusting therapeutic relationship can create the foundation for meaningful change.”
Anxiety, Depression, Family issues, Grief or loss, Maternal mental health
Creative, Holistic, Warm
Accepts 2 insurance carriers

Offers free consultationsView profile and book
Nicole Morrison

Nicole Morrison

Therapist

Virtual • New York


“My approach is both compassionate and practical, providing a safe and empowering space for you to explore, heal, and grow.”
Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Depression, Family issues, Grief or loss
Empowering, Solution-oriented, Warm
Accepts 11 insurance carriers
Rebecca Halpern

Rebecca Halpern

Therapist

Virtual • New York


“I don't believe therapy happens in a vacuum — the social, cultural, and political contexts of your life are part of the work.”
ADD/ADHD, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Depression, Family issues
Affirming, Solution-oriented, Warm
Accepts 11 insurance carriers

Offers free consultationsView profile and book
Loretta Battistoni

Loretta Battistoni

Therapist

Virtual • New York


“I believe that you are the expert of your story and that you have many strengths that will assist you in overcoming the challenges you face.”
Anxiety, Depression, Grief or loss, Physical health issues, Relationship issues
Affirming, Empowering, Warm
Accepts 6 insurance carriers
Alice Ismail

Alice Ismail

Therapist

Virtual • Brooklyn, NY


“I believe that one of the most important parts of therapy is the relationship between therapist and client.”
Anxiety, Cultural & ethnic issues, Depression, Family issues, Identity issues
Empowering, Humorous, Warm
Accepts 9 insurance carriers
Dr. Michael Nettis-Benstock

Dr. Michael Nettis-Benstock

Psychologist

Virtual • New York


I received my doctoral degree in clinical psychology from Yeshiva University's Ferkauf Graduate School of Psychology and have spent my postgraduate career working in private practice. I have particular experience in working with folks struggling with anxiety, depression, trauma, relationship difficulties and self-image.

Anger management, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Cultural & ethnic issues, Depression
Affirming, Humorous, Inquisitive
Accepts 2 insurance carriers

Offers free consultationsView profile and book
Victor Amobi

Victor Amobi

Psychiatric Mental Health NP

Virtual • New York


“He is able to utilize and apply his advanced practice and clinically acquired skills to deliver patient centered and culturally sensitive care...”
ADD/ADHD, Anger management, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Depression
Affirming, Holistic, Solution-oriented
Accepts 10 insurance carriers

Offers free consultationsView profile and book
Sheila Kissiloff

Sheila Kissiloff

Therapist

Virtual • Trumansburg, NY


“I especially enjoy working with young adults who are finding their footing: figuring out who they are outside of their family of origin, navigating a new job or career change...”
ADD/ADHD, Anger management, Anxiety, Chronic conditions, Cultural & ethnic issues
Empowering, Energetic, Open-minded
Accepts 6 insurance carriers
Marcus McGill

Marcus McGill

Psychiatric Mental Health NP

Virtual • New York


“The ultimate goal of therapy is to assist the patient in determining a treatment plan that will help them work through their mental health conditions and achieve personal growth.”
ADD/ADHD, Anger management, Anxiety, Cultural & ethnic issues, Depression
Empowering, Open-minded, Solution-oriented
Accepts 14 insurance carriers
Bex Rose

Bex Rose

Therapist

Virtual • New York


“I will not be talking at you, lecturing you, or requiring you to listen to the melodious sound of my voice for a long duration of time.”
ADD/ADHD, Anxiety, Depression, Family issues, Identity issues
Challenging, Creative, Humorous
Accepts 12 insurance carriers

Offers free consultationsView profile and book
Gloria Sanchez

Gloria Sanchez

Therapist

Virtual • New York


“My approach to working with my clients is to work with them from the place that they are at in life.”
Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Cultural & ethnic issues, Depression, End of life care
Empowering, Open-minded, Warm
Accepts 9 insurance carriers
Trina Murray

Trina Murray

Therapist

Virtual • New York


I am a warm, grounded therapist who prioritizes emotional safety while building genuine rapport. Once trust is established, I thoughtfully challenge clients in ways that promote insight and growth without undermining that sense of security. I allow glimpses of my own humanity, which helps clients feel understood while still maintaining clear professional boundaries. Overall, my style reflects a balance of compassion, depth, and seasoned clinical judgment.

Anxiety, Cultural & ethnic issues, Depression, Family issues, Identity issues
Affirming, Empowering, Warm
Accepts 5 insurance carriers
41 - 80 of

About our therapists located within 20 miles of Orchard Park, NY

Number of therapists within 20 miles of Orchard Park, NY
There are over 71 therapists in Orchard Park, NY accepting new patients.
71+
Average years in practice
Watercolor illustration of a bookshelf
7 years
Top specialties offered
Watercolor illustration of specialties
  • 100%Anxiety
  • 94%Depression
  • 83%Stress management
  • 82%Relationship issues
  • 79%Trauma
Insurances accepted
Watercolor illustration of insurance cards
  • 96%Aetna
  • 93%Cigna
  • 86%Carelon Behavioral Health
  • 56%Highmark BlueCross BlueShield of Western New York
  • 55%Curative
Languages spoken
Watercolor illustration of languages
  • 97%English
  • 1%American Sign Language
  • 1%Polish
  • 1%Spanish
How they see their clients
Watercolor illustration of therapy session
  • 100%In-person or online
Provider gender
Watercolor illustration of gender identity
  • 73%Woman
  • 27%Man
License types
Watercolor illustration of license
  • 49%Licensed Mental Health Counselor
  • 42%Licensed Clinical Social Worker
  • 3%Licensed Creative Arts Therapist
  • 3%Licensed Marriage/Family Therapist
  • 3%Nurse Practitioner
Treatment approaches
Watercolor illustration of treatment approach
  • 99%Individual therapy
  • 34%Family therapy
  • 20%Couples therapy
  • 18%Child or adolescent therapy

Frequently asked questions

Therapy Chair

Happy patient looking away

Find the right therapist for you

Headway makes it easy to find support for your mental health — from finding the right provider, to understanding costs, to scheduling with ease.

Browse by city

Explore the cities patients search for most.
1 Cost may vary based on your location, age, and insurance coverage.