Find a therapist in Amityville, NY — covered by insurance


Top therapists in Amityville, NY accepting new patients
Find mental health support in Amityville, NY across neighborhoods like Copiague, Lindenhurst, and Massapequa. Headway connects you with 8,378 licensed providers offering flexible in-person or virtual sessions covered by insurance, with many patients paying as little as $0 per visit.
I love counseling – both giving and receiving. For over 40 years, I have helped adoptive families utilizing my law and counseling degrees.
The counseling aspect spans a wide range of populations, including tweens, seniors, singles, couples, and multiple family members.
I met my wife at graduate school while working on my Master’s in Social Work, and we have since adopted three children.
I’m an experienced licensed mental health counselor and I believe that meaningful therapy starts with a genuine human connection. The relationship between client and therapist is at the heart of my work and I strive to create a space that feels warm, comfortable, and free of judgment. I bring curiosity, compassion, and humor into the room and I focus on attuning to each client’s unique needs so therapy feels personal, collaborative, and real.
While I aim to be supportive and affirming, I also believe growth often requires gentle challenge. I work to help clients notice patterns, stretch beyond what feels familiar, and engage honestly with themselves—always at a pace that feels respectful and manageable. My approach is integrative and tailored to each person or couple I work with. I’m trained in EMDR and also draw from CBT, DBT, Motivational Interviewing, and psychodynamic approaches. I enjoy working with individuals and couples, with areas of focus that include trauma, relationship concerns, anxiety, depression, substance use, self-esteem, and identity. Whether you’re looking to heal, gain insight, or make meaningful change, I’ll walk alongside you with warmth, honesty, and intention.
I view therapy as a collaborative process where clients are invited to make sense of their experiences in a way that feels authentic to them. Rather than directing the process, I focus on creating a supportive environment where individuals can speak openly, reflect at their own pace, and gain insight into their thoughts and emotions. In the midst of busy and often overwhelming daily life, having intentional time to pause and look inward can be a powerful part of personal growth.
Creating room for reflection can open the door to new perspectives and a deeper awareness of internal experiences. As clients begin to better understand their emotional responses and patterns, they often find greater clarity in how they relate to themselves and others. This increased awareness can support more intentional decision-making and help guide the next steps in their personal growth.
Hi, I’m Yitzchok Wagshul. One day, my young grandson asked me what kind of doctor I am. I’m a clinical psychologist, so I replied, “I’m the kind of doctor who helps sad people feel happy.” He looked at me and said, “Zaidy,” (that’s “Grandpa” in Yiddish) "that’s not being a doctor, that’s just being nice!” That’s a cute story, but I want to tell you something: the better part of therapy is “being nice.” I know a lot of psychology. But if I didn’t respect each person I work with, if I didn’t view them with complete acceptance and unconditional positive regard, all of that would be worthless, because no one would listen to me.
Hello, my name is Matthew Cosentino and I'm a licensed mental health counselor. I've worked with clients of all backgrounds and with various reasons that brought them to counseling. I know first hand what it's like to go through things like anxiety and depression and I specialize in working with people facing those challenges. I believe that even during life's most difficult seasons, there is hope ahead. I strive to help clients find the light at the end of the tunnel and build the tools needed to move toward a brighter future.
Psychodynamic psychotherapy based on psychoanalytical self psychology training.
About our therapists located within 20 miles of Amityville, NY



- 98%Anxiety
- 96%Depression
- 88%Stress management
- 81%Family issues
- 78%Relationship issues

- 99%Aetna
- 87%Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield New York
- 86%Cigna
- 81%Carelon Behavioral Health
- 64%Oxford

- 97%English
- 12%Spanish
- 4%Haitian Creole
- 4%Hebrew
- 4%Russian

- 95%In-person or online
- 5%In-person only

- 80%Woman
- 20%Man

- 40%Licensed Clinical Social Worker
- 29%Licensed Mental Health Counselor
- 14%Nurse Practitioner
- 10%Clinical Psychologist
- 4%Licensed Marriage/Family Therapist

- 100%Individual therapy
- 35%Family therapy
- 32%Child or adolescent therapy
- 22%Couples therapy
Frequently asked questions


Find the right therapist for you
Headway makes it easy to find support for your mental health — from finding the right provider, to understanding costs, to scheduling with ease.
Browse by city
Explore the cities patients search for most.- Massapequa, NY
- Farmingdale, NY
- Wantagh, NY
- Babylon, NY
- West Islip, NY
- Merrick, NY
- Plainview, NY
- Deer Park, NY
- East Meadow, NY
- Melville, NY
- Hicksville, NY
- Hempstead, NY
- Rockville Centre, NY
- Garden City, NY
- East Islip, NY
- Mineola, NY
- Commack, NY
- Huntington, NY
- Lynbrook, NY
- Roslyn Heights, NY
- Long Beach, NY
- New Hyde Park, NY
- Hauppauge, NY
- Valley Stream, NY
- Floral Park, NY
- Cedarhurst, NY
- Smithtown, NY
- Manhasset, NY
- Bohemia, NY
- Ronkonkoma, NY
- Port Washington, NY
- Sayville, NY
- Great Neck, NY
- Holbrook, NY
- Jamaica, NY
- Patchogue, NY
- Stony Brook, NY
- Flushing, NY
- Forest Hills, NY
- Rego Park, NY
- Medford, NY
- Corona, NY
- Larchmont, NY
- Mamaroneck, NY
- Ridgewood, NY
- New Rochelle, NY
- Harrison, NY
- Port Jefferson Station, NY
- Port Jefferson, NY
- Bronx, NY
- Astoria, NY
- Mount Vernon, NY
- Brooklyn, NY
- Long Island City, NY
- Scarsdale, NY
- White Plains, NY
- Yonkers, NY
- New York, NY
- Tarrytown, NY
- Pleasantville, NY
- Nyack, NY
- Staten Island, NY
- Mount Kisco, NY
- Nanuet, NY
- New City, NY
- Suffern, NY
- Woodbury, NY
- Warwick, NY
- New Windsor, NY
- Beacon, NY
- Fishkill, NY
- Newburgh, NY
- Goshen, NY
- Middletown, NY
- Poughkeepsie, NY
- New Paltz, NY
- Rhinebeck, NY
- Kingston, NY
- Hudson, NY
- Rensselaer, NY
- Albany, NY
- Troy, NY
- Oneonta, NY
- Schenectady, NY
- Clifton Park, NY
- Binghamton, NY
- Johnson City, NY
- Saratoga Springs, NY
- Endicott, NY
- Glens Falls, NY
- New Hartford, NY
- Utica, NY
- Ithaca, NY
- Elmira, NY
- Rome, NY
- Fayetteville, NY
- Corning, NY
- East Syracuse, NY
- Syracuse, NY
- Liverpool, NY
- Auburn, NY
- Fulton, NY
- Canandaigua, NY
- Pittsford, NY
- Webster, NY
- Orchard Park, NY
- Hamburg, NY
- Jamestown, NY
- Buffalo, NY
- Lockport, NY







































