Skip to main content
Headway

Find a Cigna therapist in Independence, OH

Book a therapist or psychiatrist in Independence, OH covered by Cigna

Therapist and patient in a therapy session
Calculator Illustration
Get a cost estimate
People with insurance pay as low as $0 per session through Headway

Top Cigna-covered therapists and psychiatrists in Independence, OH

Access affordable therapy and medication management through Cigna in Independence, where patients typically save 75% on sessions. Headway connects you with available providers within two weeks for personalized mental healthcare.

Christy Barnes

Christy Barnes

Therapist

Virtual • Ohio


“I believe therapy should feel like a safe, supportive space where you can be honest, feel understood, and develop practical tools for real-life change.”

ADD/ADHD, Anger management, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder,

Empowering, Solution-oriented, Warm

Accepts Cigna, Aetna, Aetna Medicare Advantage,

Robert Kollar

Robert Kollar

Psychiatric Mental Health NP

Virtual • Ohio


“A typical appointment consists of empathetic listening, discussing options, and arriving mutually at a decision that fits your life.”

ADD/ADHD, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Depression,

Open-minded, Solution-oriented, Warm

Accepts Cigna, Aetna, United Healthcare,

Alexandra Scholl

Alexandra Scholl

Psychiatric Mental Health NP

Virtual • Cincinnati, OH


If you’ve been feeling anxious, down, overwhelmed, or unable to focus, I want to understand what that looks like in your everyday life. I’m curious by nature, I ask questions, and I take your experience seriously. My approach to psychiatry considers how your physical health, sleep, stress, and lifestyle may be contributing to how you feel.

ADD/ADHD, Anxiety, Depression, Family issues,

Holistic, Inquisitive, Open-minded

Accepts Cigna, Aetna, Carelon Behavioral Health,

James Reed

James Reed

Therapist

Virtual • Cleveland, OH


“I believe healing isn't linear, growth often requires becoming comfortable with the uncomfortable, and your past doesn't have to define your future.”

Anger management, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Cultural & ethnic issues,

Affirming, Empowering, Solution-oriented

Accepts Cigna, Aetna, Carelon Behavioral Health,

Sara Bojorquez

Sara Bojorquez

Therapist

Virtual & in-person

202 North Defiance Street, Archbold, OH

“You are the expert of your own life. I will spend time learning what brings you into counseling and you sharing what is most pressing to talk about.”

ADD/ADHD, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Depression,

Affirming, Empowering, Warm

Accepts Cigna, Aetna, Aetna Medicare Advantage,

Michael Barnes

Michael Barnes

Psychiatric Mental Health NP

Virtual • Ohio


“I believe that every individual is unique, and I tailor treatment plans to fit your needs and goals.”

ADD/ADHD, Anger management, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder,

Affirming, Holistic, Solution-oriented

Accepts Cigna, Aetna, United Healthcare,

Amy Deem

Amy Deem

Therapist

Virtual • Ohio


“I believe therapy can be meaningful without feeling heavy all the time, and I often bring warmth, honesty, and a little humor into the process.”

Anger management, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Chronic conditions,

Empowering, Humorous, Warm

Accepts Cigna, Aetna, Carelon Behavioral Health,

Taylor Price

Taylor Price

Therapist

Virtual • Ohio


“Therapy isn't about fixing you—it's about helping you access your own strength, clarity, and capacity for change.”

Anger management, Anxiety, Chronic conditions, Depression,

Challenging, Humorous, Open-minded

Accepts Cigna, Aetna, Aetna Medicare Advantage,


Offers free consultationsView profile and book
Dr. Shelle Mathis

Dr. Shelle Mathis

Therapist

Virtual • Ohio


Hello! I believe that healing is possible for everyone, no matter how difficult life may feel right now. My goal is to create a supportive, nonjudgmental environment where you feel heard, valued, and empowered to work through life's challenges.


I take a compassionate and professional approach to therapy, combining evidence-based clinical practices with Christian principles when desired by the client. I view counseling as a collaborative process and am committed to helping individuals, couples, families, ministry leaders, and professionals develop the tools and insights needed to create meaningful, lasting change.


Whether you are struggling with anxiety, depression, trauma, relationship concerns, or a major life transition, I will meet you where you are and walk alongside you on your journey toward healing, growth, and restoration. My focus is not only on helping you overcome current challenges but also on equipping you with the skills and confidence needed to thrive moving forward.

ADD/ADHD, Anger management, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder,

Empowering, Humorous, Warm

Accepts Cigna, Aetna, Carelon Behavioral Health,


Offers free consultationsView profile and book
Jamila Tippit

Jamila Tippit

Therapist

Virtual • Ohio


I am a Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist in the state of Florida and Ohio with 14 years of direct counseling experience. Supporting and guiding clients through difficult traumas and life's challenges in a safe and nonjudgmental environment is what I strive for.

My goal is to assist children, adolescents, and adults to reach their highest potential and to help couples and families live more harmonious and joyful lives together.

My passion is to support, uplift and encourage those in my community. Let's work together to start living a better-quality life one session at a time.

ADD/ADHD, Anger management, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder,

Affirming, Empowering, Warm

Accepts Cigna, Aetna, Carelon Behavioral Health,

Ashley Strawther

Ashley Strawther

Therapist

Virtual • Ohio


“Therapy is a partnership. You are the expert of your own story, and my approach is to listen first before becoming involved in your narrative.”

ADD/ADHD, Anxiety, Cultural & ethnic issues, Depression,

Empowering, Open-minded, Solution-oriented

Accepts Cigna, Aetna, Carelon Behavioral Health,

Elisa Frazier

Elisa Frazier

Therapist

Virtual • Ohio


“I tend to utilize cognitive behavior, solution-focused, psychodynamic as well as acceptance and commitment therapy.”

ADD/ADHD, Anger management, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder,

Affirming, Empowering, Humorous

Accepts Cigna, Aetna, Carelon Behavioral Health,


Offers free consultationsView profile and book
Sarah Julian-Brown

Sarah Julian-Brown

Therapist

Virtual • Ohio


“My approach is warm, engaging, and grounded in evidence-based care. I draw from Cognitive Behavioral Therapy and Narrative Therapy to help clients better understand their patterns, and create meaningful change.”

ADD/ADHD, Anxiety, Depression, End of life care,

Empowering, Humorous, Warm

Accepts Cigna, Aetna, Carelon Behavioral Health,

Adrian Calhoun

Adrian Calhoun

Therapist

Virtual & in-person

132 Northwoods Boulevard, Columbus, OH

“Clients often describe my style as warm, steady, and collaborative. I value meeting you exactly where you are...”

ADD/ADHD, Anger management, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder,

Empowering, Holistic, Warm

Accepts Cigna, Aetna, Carelon Behavioral Health,

Theresa Nemenz

Theresa Nemenz

Therapist

Virtual • Ohio


“I consider therapy to be a partnership with you during which we work toward helping you to feel more comfortable with yourself and toward feeling more empowered.”

Anger management, Anxiety, Depression, Family issues,

Empowering, Open-minded, Warm

Accepts Cigna, Aetna, Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts

Lisa Cioffi

Lisa Cioffi

Therapist

Virtual • Ohio


“I focus on evidenced based techniques to help you achieve your goals of treatment with my main goal of meeting you where you are in your journey.”

ADD/ADHD, Anxiety, Depression, Family issues,

Empowering, Open-minded, Participatory

Accepts Cigna, Aetna, United Healthcare,

Shavon Bills-Gabriel

Shavon Bills-Gabriel

Psychiatric Mental Health NP

Virtual • Ohio


Welcome. If you are an adult or adolescent in Ohio feeling overwhelmed or stuck, I provide a safe, collaborative space for your mental health journey. I see you as a whole person, not a list of symptoms. Typically, individuals seek psychiatric care when coping mechanisms are no longer enough for persistent anxiety, depression, stress, or mood disorders. Together, we start with a comprehensive psychiatric evaluation to understand your history and goals. If chosen, medication management is introduced thoughtfully at conservative doses and paired with supportive tools to help you build real-world skills and truly thrive.

Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Depression, Panic disorders,

Open-minded, Solution-oriented, Warm

Accepts Cigna, Aetna, United Healthcare,

Aysha Mendez

Aysha Mendez

Therapist

Virtual • Ohio


“I bring a multicultural lens to every session, and when faith matters to you, I know how to hold that too.”

Anxiety, Cultural & ethnic issues, Depression, Family issues,

Empowering, Holistic, Warm

Accepts Cigna, Aetna, Carelon Behavioral Health,


Offers free consultationsView profile and book
Christopher Settel

Christopher Settel

Therapist

Virtual • Ohio


“I have over 25 years of experience working with adults and adolescents in behavioral health. I work from a solution-focused perspective and use a variety of techniques to engage clients.”

Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Chronic conditions, Depression,

Direct, Humorous, Solution-oriented

Accepts Cigna, Aetna, United Healthcare,

Danelle Giammarco

Danelle Giammarco

Psychiatric Mental Health NP

Virtual • Ohio


“I take a person-centered approach meaning that we work together, I will always listen to your concerns, and focus will be helping you feel your best...”

Anger management, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Chronic conditions,

Creative, Open-minded, Warm

Accepts Cigna, Aetna, Carelon Behavioral Health,

Stephen Marley

Stephen Marley

Therapist

Virtual • Ohio


“With 34+ years of experience, I help adults and couples navigate anxiety, stress, grief, relationship challenges, burnout, and major life transitions.”

Anxiety, Chronic conditions, Depression, End of life care,

Direct, Solution-oriented, Warm

Accepts Cigna, Aetna, Medical Mutual of Ohio,

Gina Elston

Gina Elston

Therapist

Virtual • Ohio


“I offer a trauma-informed, affirming space to process complex emotions, reduce stress, and build resilience.”

Anxiety, Chronic conditions, Depression, Family issues,

Affirming, Creative, Humorous

Accepts Cigna, Aetna, Medical Mutual of Ohio,

Sonya Williams

Sonya Williams

Therapist

Virtual • Ohio


“My approach is practical and rooted in who you actually are — not who therapy says you should become.”

Anxiety, Cultural & ethnic issues, Depression, Family issues,

Empowering, Open-minded, Warm

Accepts Cigna, Aetna, Medical Mutual of Ohio,

Dr. David Stefan

Dr. David Stefan

Therapist

Virtual • Ohio


Hello & Welcome — I’m glad you’re here.


I’m a Licensed Professional Clinical Counselor with a Ph.D. in Counseling, along with graduate training in both counseling and theology.


I work with men (gay, straight, bi, and curious) as they navigate identity, faith, mental health and vocation.


Over the years, I’ve worked as a therapist, college professor/administrator, coach, and educator, and that range of experience has shaped the way I approach counseling: with curiosity, compassion, and a deep respect for the complexity of each person’s story. I work with men (gay, straight, bi, and curious) as they navigate identity, faith and vocation.

Anxiety, Depression, Identity issues, LGBTQIA+,

Empowering, Open-minded, Warm

Accepts Cigna, Aetna, Carelon Behavioral Health,

Christy Stinton

Christy Stinton

Therapist

Virtual • Ohio


I'm a licensed professional counselor with over 20 years of experience working with adults navigating some of life's hardest seasons — infertility, adoption, depression, anxiety, life transitions, and the kind of grief that doesn't have a clear name yet. I'm faith-integrated in my approach, which means I honor the role spirituality plays in your life without ever making it a requirement. My clients describe me as warm, easy to talk to, and refreshingly direct. I don't do one-size-fits-all therapy — every treatment plan starts with your story.

Anger management, Anxiety, Chronic conditions, Depression,

Affirming, Empowering, Warm

Accepts Cigna, Aetna, Carelon Behavioral Health,


Offers free consultationsView profile and book
Maria Racadio Seltman

Maria Racadio Seltman

Therapist

Virtual • Ohio


“I approach therapy from the belief that every person has innate potential—and with the right support, can grow, flourish, and thrive.”

ADD/ADHD, Anxiety, Depression, Family issues,

Creative, Solution-oriented, Warm

Accepts Cigna, Aetna, Carelon Behavioral Health,

Kimberly Babcock

Kimberly Babcock

Therapist

Virtual • Toledo, OH


“Athletes learn early: push through, shake it off, the team comes first. It works — until it doesn't.”

Anxiety, Depression, Grief or loss, Physical health issues,

Energetic, Open-minded, Warm

Accepts Cigna, Aetna, Carelon Behavioral Health,

Ted Faneuff

Ted Faneuff

Therapist

Virtual • Ohio


“I am relatable and focus on building a trusted therapeutic relationship. The work of therapy is hard so expect that I will come along side you and validate and support you but also continue to challenge you to get the best results you hope for!”

Anxiety, Depression, End of life care, Grief or loss,

Empowering, Humorous, Warm

Accepts Cigna, Aetna, Carelon Behavioral Health

Candace Neff

Candace Neff

Therapist

Virtual • Ohio


“My goal is to offer a steady, non‐judgmental space where you can exhale, feel understood, and begin talking through whatever you're carrying at your own pace...”

ADD/ADHD, Anxiety, Cultural & ethnic issues, Depression,

Affirming, Empowering, Warm

Accepts Cigna, Aetna, Carelon Behavioral Health,

Herbert Lomax

Herbert Lomax

Therapist

Virtual • Ohio


“I am a mental health therapist with over a decade of experience in helping BIPOC professionals and couples break free from burnout, perfectionism, and imposter feelings.”

ADD/ADHD, Anger management, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder,

Affirming, Empowering, Warm

Accepts Cigna, Aetna, Carelon Behavioral Health


Offers free consultationsView profile and book
Terry Pryor

Terry Pryor

Therapist

Virtual • Ohio


I built my practice around a conviction I've held since I started in this field: you are capable of more than the patterns that have been holding you back. My job is to help you see that clearly and give you the tools to act on it.

As a Black male therapist with a supervisor-level license (LPCC-S) and a certification in Trauma-Focused CBT, I bring both clinical depth and lived perspective to my work — particularly for men, for clients navigating trauma and its ripple effects, and for couples trying to understand each other across that pain.

I'm licensed in Ohio and Pennsylvania, trained at Youngstown State University, and serve clients via telehealth across both states with flexible morning, evening, and weekend availability.

Anger management, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Cultural & ethnic issues,

Affirming, Challenging, Empowering

Accepts Cigna, Aetna, Carelon Behavioral Health

Meghan Fawcett

Meghan Fawcett

Therapist

Virtual • Boardman, OH


“I take a nonjudgmental, down-to-earth approach and strive to create a space where you feel comfortable being honest, even when the topics are hard or emotionally heavy.”

ADD/ADHD, Anger management, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder,

Empowering, Open-minded, Warm

Accepts Cigna, Aetna, Medical Mutual of Ohio,

Dr. Vivienne Nkengafac

Dr. Vivienne Nkengafac

Psychiatric Mental Health NP

Virtual • Ohio


“Ms. Nkengafac maintains a friendly, empathetic, and non-judgmental attitude during consultations, ensuring patients express themselves freely.”

ADD/ADHD, Anger management, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder,

Holistic, Open-minded, Warm

Accepts Cigna, Aetna, United Healthcare,

Dr. Sandra Parawira, D.N.P., P.M.H.N.P.-B.C., A.G.A.C.N.P.-B.C.

Dr. Sandra Parawira, D.N.P., P.M.H.N.P.-B.C., A.G.A.C.N.P.-B.C.

Psychiatric Mental Health NP

Virtual • Ohio


“My approach to care is collaborative and individualized. I believe in taking the time to understand each person's unique experiences, concerns, and goals while creating a safe and supportive environment where they feel heard and respected.”

Anxiety, Chronic conditions, Depression, Grief or loss,

Direct, Open-minded, Solution-oriented

Accepts Cigna, Aetna, Carelon Behavioral Health,

Juanita Ellis

Juanita Ellis

Psychiatric Mental Health NP

Virtual • Toledo, OH


“I focus on solution based outcomes. I am very open minded and focus on building a rapport with all my clients.”

Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Depression, Family issues,

Open-minded, Solution-oriented, Warm

Accepts Cigna, Aetna, United Healthcare,

Tanisha Richardson

Tanisha Richardson

Therapist

Virtual • Ohio


“Together we can develop a restorative approach through the use of one-on-one interventions, tailored coping techniques, and personalized methods to assist in moving forward.”

Anxiety, Cultural & ethnic issues, Depression, Eating disorders,

Empowering, Open-minded, Warm

Accepts Cigna, Aetna, Carelon Behavioral Health

Linda Marcel-Rene

Linda Marcel-Rene

Therapist

Virtual • Ohio


“My practice is sex-positive, relationship-affirming, and grounded in the belief that therapy should make room for who you actually are rather than expecting you to fit into someone else's idea of what your life or relationships should look like.”

Bipolar disorder, Depression, Identity issues, LGBTQIA+,

Creative, Empowering, Open-minded

Accepts Cigna, Aetna, Carelon Behavioral Health,

Carolyn McCreary

Carolyn McCreary

Psychologist

Virtual • Ohio


I have a PhD in Psychology, and completed a two year post-doctoral fellowship in Neuropsychology. I have expanded my practice to include work in other areas such as anxiety, depression, post-traumatic and complex -post traumatic stress disorder. I have also worked extensively with children and adults with various physical/medical and developmental disorders.

ADD/ADHD, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder, Chronic conditions,

Affirming, Empowering, Warm

Accepts Cigna, Aetna, Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts

Sema Contreras

Sema Contreras

Therapist

Virtual • Ohio


“I believe in working alongside my clients to explore their thoughts and feelings, identify the core of their challenges, and build practical tools to manage and move through them.”

Anxiety, Depression, End of life care, Family issues,

Empowering, Open-minded, Warm

Accepts Cigna, Aetna, Carelon Behavioral Health,

Oluwatobi Ojo

Oluwatobi Ojo

Therapist

Virtual • Ohio


As a dual holistic practitioner, I acknowledge that prioritizing and actualizing mental health wellness are essential keys to balance and stability in life. I applaud you for leaping and getting support for your healing or rediscovery journey. You have achieved the first major milestone!

ADD/ADHD, Anger management, Anxiety, Bipolar disorder,

Empowering, Holistic, Solution-oriented

Accepts Cigna, Aetna, Carelon Behavioral Health,

What type of therapy does Cigna cover?

Cigna plans can vary, but many cover a range of therapy types. Below are some common options that may be included in your coverage.
watercolor illustration of a coffee table with tea

Frequently asked questions

Therapy Chair

Happy patient looking away

Affordable care that fits you — and your Cigna plan

Headway makes it easy to get affordable in-network mental health care with Cigna — from finding the right therapist or psychiatrist, to understanding costs, to booking your first session.

1 Cost may vary based on your location, age, and insurance coverage.